Yet Wednesday’s rant continues…
I think I’m madder today than I was yesterday, so if it looks like I’m staging a coup…well, I might be. But the interesting part in all of this…seems like almost everyone in HOCKEYDOM agrees with me on this.
So let’s start off with why Colin Campbell (NHL disciplinarian) has gotten me so worked up this morning.
This morning, the Senior VP and Director of Hockey Operations was on Fan590 this morning. As much as I did my best not to call in and give Mr. Campbell some thoughts of my own, I see this come across Twitter:
@FriedmanHNIC On FAN, Colin Campbell says Auger was told he brought up Smithson incident to Burrows at an “inappropriate time.”
Elliotte Friedman-Hockey Night In Canada reporter
So everything that Alexandre Burrows said was true.
But I’m not done with what got me so fired up…
Here’s the official press release from the NHL that was released yesterday on the Burrows incident:
Vancouver Canucks forward Alex Burrows has been fined $2,500 for conduct deemed detrimental to the National Hockey League and the game of hockey, the NHL announced today.
On separate plays during the third period of a 3-2 Vancouver loss to the Nashville Predators Jan. 10, Referee Stephane Auger assessed Burrows minor penalties for diving, interference and unsportsmanlike conduct.
After the game, Burrows made the following comments to the media: “It was personal. It started in warm up before the anthem. The ref (Auger) came over to me and said I made him look bad in Nashville on the Smithson hit (during a game December 8, 2009). He said he was going to get me back tonight and he did his job in the third . . . “
Burrows said his teammates “are battling hard for 60 minutes to win a hockey game because every two points are so huge, so important, and because of a guy’s ego it just blows everything out of proportion and they’re making bad calls and the fans are paying for it and we’re paying for it.
“I think he (Auger) should sit out the rest of the year making calls like that.”
NHL Senior Executive Vice President of Hockey Operations Colin Campbell issued the following statement:
“The National Hockey League will not tolerate the personal nature of the comments Mr. Burrows directed at Referee Auger or the fact that he brought into question the integrity of both the official and the game.
“We have determined that Mr. Burrows’ account of Referee Auger’s comments to him before the game, and specifically Burrows’ suggestion that these comments indicated bias against the player or the Vancouver team, cannot be substantiated. While Referee Auger engaged the player in a brief conversation prior to the opening face-off, I firmly believe that nothing inappropriate was said and that Referee Auger’s intentions were beyond reproach.”
Like I’ve said before, I understand why the league fined Burrows. That is understandable.
But what I don’t understand is why Auger got away scott free.
I also want to point out the contradictions in the NHL’s official press release and what was said by Campbell this morning. “CANNOT BE SUBSTANTIATED” are the words I’m looking at…followed by “nothing inappropriate was said”…it’s like saying that Burrows LIED. But, Campbell’s comment this morning indicates that Burrows DID NOT LIE and that Auger’s ‘timing’ was at an ‘inappropriate time’.
Ummm…WHAT THE F*CK?!?!?!
[Sorry, I'm not controlling my language today.]
Since Burrows has brought to light that something is wrong in the face of officiating…that there are indeed vendettas being played out on the ice against the players by the officials…he’s the one the league has sided against?
Two wrongs don’t make a right.
Going back to professionalism in this league…Campbell’s decision in this matter says that the league officially endorses, upholds and will protect this kind of officiating.
The kind of officiating that I am adamantly against: personal vendettas being played out during the game against a player/team. There is no fairness to the game when this happens.
I had always had this feeling that some of the calls that were/were not being made were done on purpose. It seems like that feeling may be substantiated.
The league absolutely cannot allow officials to act like gods in the game. They are not gods. When a personal vendetta is played out, you may as well expect that team to lose, because a goal can be called off so easily, a whistle blown to stop the goal from happening, or even a player can be assessed a game misconduct that costs the team the game.
This is the same as knowing what the game’s outcome will be at the start of the game depending on who the official is. So if you’re the betting kind, you’d do well to get in on what officials hate which players/teams that they may have a personal vendetta to play out against. You’d be rolling in the dough.
I’d also like to point out another factor in here. There is a double standard in the league. You are either part of the “it” crowd or you’re in the “out” crowd. I know a little too much about this, because it works when you’re part of the media, too.
Burrows falls into the “out” crowd. He’s one of those guys that you love if he’s on your team, hate when he’s not on your team. To me, I say he’s just doing his job.
Campbell tends to hand out punishments according to whether the player is in the “it” crowd or not. If you’re not in the “it” crowd like Idunno…Sidney Crosby, Alexander Ovechkin, etc. then you are assessed some BS fines, etc. from Mr. Campbell. There’s no fairness in his disciplinary actions.
Ovechkin and Georges Laraque can do the exact same thing to somebody. Ovie doesn’t care because he’s protected by the league. The most he gets is time to sit out and ice his knee (1-2 games). Laraque will get five games for the exact same offense. This is what we call the double standard.
In Burrows case, he was dealt that exact same hand that Laraque has complained adamantly about on his blog. It’s not right.
For the league to be ok with Campbell dishing out punishment with a double standard attached to it…I question why they keep him or why we should even give a rat’s ass about the NHL if this is the kind of dirty organization they want to keep going.
Fans pay money to see their team. They pay money to see their favorite players play hockey. They pay money to see a real hockey game played by the rules and played fairly. The last thing they want to see and know…is that there’s a dirty side to hockey…one that protects referees who want to act out personal vendettas; and one that will sanction the hell out of your favorite player just because he’s not part of the “it” crowd.
Now that we know that we can expect to lose a game based on what official is in the game…I don’t think we can respect the game of NHL hockey anymore.
Commissioner Bettman, I think it’s time you stepped in on this matter. You just hired someone that I think would be a perfect fit for the disciplinarian job. At least I know that he would look at both sides of the equation and try to come up with a fair assessment on any matter that could spring up in the league. I would respect his judgment because historically he has done his best to come out with a fair judgment for everyone in the matter. His name is Brendan Shanahan.
With the number of fans that are mad over Campbell’s decision in this matter, I think it’s time that Mr. Bettman step in and activate some change in this league.
Here are a few responses from fans that learned that Campbell would be on NHL Live today to discuss the Auger/Burrows decision. You can find these exact comments on the NHL’s Facebook page [UPDATE: The NHL took the status down, so you will only find the comments here]:
The ruling was pure and utter BS.
Couldn’t have said it better myself.
Agree on that. Been in a game like that and how are you suppose to record the ref says something like that to you.
Maintaining the integrity of the game? By firing the stupid referee you are maintaining the integrity of the game.
Didn’t expect anything different.
ref’s in the NHL need some serious discipline as the majority of them are crap. But what do you expect when the management from the NHL is crap as well.
fuck campbell,bettmen and auger
That ref doesnt deserve to skate another game
That Ref Should Be Kicked Out Of The League.
Who cares? Bettman and Campbell are a disgrace to our sport.
he is one of the worst refs in the nhl good bye auger!
Auger needs to go back to refereeing school!!!
Auger need to review is referee school book….and Burrows need to shut up
Alex shoulda complained about the comments before the game, not after…maybe then people would have been more inclined to believe him
I’m appalled that the NHL not only sided with Auger, but fined Burrows. My respect for the League has dropped considerably.
Inconsistency in calls, vendettas, showing preference for one team over another, early whistles that prevent a goal from being counted…and who knows what else is going on during a game. The refs and linesmen should be held accountable for each game. The officials should not have a “God” status where they are untouchable. Players get fines and suspensions so the officials should also get some sort of discipline or performance review at least.
Too many teams = less talent = more games = more refs needed = less quality refs overall = bad hockey = this Go back to 24 teams. Nashville doesn’t need a fucking hockey team. Nor does Florida need two, Phoenix need one, California need three, Atlanta (there’s a reason the Flames left in 1980 idiots) need one. That’s 4 teams right there, and take your pick of any other two teams.
he should have pulled Auger’s hair
Its a small fine, they must believe him to an extent. Or the fine would have been larger. They fined him to prove a point to the rest of the league that its not appropriate.
Auger is a loser and it doesn’t shock me
and Burrows should have been fined. You don’t complain about officials to the media… you tell your teams NHLPA rep and let the NHLPA go to the league.
Wondering if Bob McKenzie’s latest article has something to do with Campbell discussing the issue publicly… http://tsn.ca/blogs/bob_mckenzie/?id=305937
I agree that the Canucks were screwed, but Campbell and Betman will back THERE ref. I’m a 20+ yr fan. I will no longer watch or spend money on a game that is clearly manipulated by it’s officials. So a big Thank you Auger, you whinny french canadian. Get over it we all don’t dislike the french.
it’s true what joe dewaters said, go back to a smaller league, and kick out toronto too
yea when they say he is a top official and hasnt done but 10 playoff games…cmon this guy is far ffrom a good ref.dude has blown calls all season(brad may in detroit)
Joseph, it’s not about Auger being a poor official, its about Auger letting personal issues get in the way of calling the calling the game correctly.
I don’t think anybody would argue that being an NHL official is easy… half these people can’t skate at public sessions, let alone keep up with NHLers AND stay the hell out of the way, while trying to call the game.
from what i have read, this is not the first time Auger has had issues with players, time to send this clown packing and tell him to ref pee wee league games…Bettman and Campbell are both schmucks for not giving the ref any punishment, typical NHL crap
Being a ref deserves respect, except when you have a personal opinion of a player , and you make calls outside the boundaries of the position. Auger needs to be investigated.
so because youve been a referee, youre saying it s ok to
to call phantom calls against players who fooled you games ago. wake up
Hey Joseph nice try it’s pretty plain to see that the refs need to be held accountable for their actions. It pisses me right off when you have 4 striped shirts out there & blatent calls are over looked on one team & the the stupidist little fucking thing is called on the other team.. It’s not only in the NHL take for example the FUCKING gold metal …
I find it interesting that Colin Campbell is going to talk about an issue that was supposed to be closed. It’ll be interesting to hear what he has to say, if he says anything at all beyond “the issue is closed”.
Burrows got the max fine that is allowed by the CBA, if it could have been higher it probably would have, he should not have gone to the media he should have gone to the captain or coach right away and the NHLPA after the game. Does not dismiss that the NHL has reffing issues. With ref’s having vendetta’s against certain players (it happens on every team) and ref’s like Chris Lee who want to be the star of the game and clearly favour certain teams things need to change in the NHL.